I hate when I watch sports and find myself thinking more about something dumb an announcer said than actually reflecting on the game itself.
But during the fourth quarter of the first game of the series between the Suns and the Pelicans, TNT broadcaster Reggie Miller said something colossally upsetting, and I’m afraid that I can’t let it go.
New Orleans rookie Herbert Jones was making his way back to defend Chris Paul, which was his primary defensive role on Sunday. He did a fantastic job at that, too, as the veteran guard scored nearly all his points when guarded by other players on the Pelicans.
While hurrying back to cover his assignment, Jones made inadvertent contact with Phoenix big Deandre Ayton. Jones’ shoulder hit Ayton in the jaw and the center was left feeling woozy.
Herb Jones clips Deandre Ayton with his shoulder on this play.
As per Reggie Miller, it was INTENTIONAL. Y'all agree? 🤔pic.twitter.com/F40Xkjw58E
— ClutchPoints (@ClutchPointsApp) April 18, 2022
Miller took a look at the replay and came away with an assessment: This was intentional. To his credit, Miller played the game at an elite level and perhaps he saw something others did not.
Here is what he said, courtesy of a replay from the TNT broadcast:
“This might have been on purpose. In fact, I think it was. Because there is no need for Jones to rotate over like that. Yeah, that’s on purpose.”
However, when the officials took a look, they did not reach the same conclusion about malicious intent. For what it’s worth, after the game, both Ayton himself and Phoenix head coach Monty Williams said they did not feel that the hit was intentional.
Monty McCutchen, the senior vice president of referee development and training, concluded that Jones attempted to maneuver his way to become the on-ball defender.
Herb Jones tries to jump out of the way of Ayton
Reggie Miller lost his mind pic.twitter.com/aLAJvjvFKP
— Tony Clements (@TonyCMKE) April 18, 2022
He determined Jones and Ayton didn’t see one another, there was no wind-up; then, once contact was made, the rookie then checked in to make sure Ayton was okay.
Miller wouldn’t it go, and continued to spew this reckless take:
“I don’t know, Monty. That’s not incidental contact because Herb Jones knew exactly where he was going and he knew that Ayton did not see him.”
I can’t say whether Jones intended to hit Ayton, but I know during the pre-draft process, the Alabama defensive standout was touted as someone with high character.
Jones doesn’t have a reputation as a violent player. He has collected just two technical fouls and only one flagrant foul during his NBA career thus far, though many felt the one flagrant Jones received last month was excessive.
Regardless, Miller seemingly went out of his way to say Jones was malicious. But as noted by CBS Sports’ Sam Quinn, that sort of rhetoric from Miller could shape Jones’ reputation.
People know Miller, and by proxy, many trust him. Not as many know Jones, so when they hear a Hall-of-Famer like Miller suggest Jones is a dirty player, that is damaging and unfair. I’m not the only one who feels this way, as many NBA fans took to Twitter to express their disappointment in Miller’s actions.
If it's not really, blatantly obvious, I don't like broadcasters calling hits intentional.
Herb Jones is a rookie in one of his first high-visibility games. Reggie going in on him like that could affect his reputation. At least based on what I've seen, he's not a dirty player.
— Sam Quinn (@SamQuinnCBS) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller saying that was clearly intentional is one of the more absurd pieces of live commentary in recent memory.
— Gabe Brooks (@gabrieldbrooks) April 18, 2022
Get Reggie Miller out of the booth. Saying Jones did that on purpose when he’s clearly focused on picking up CP3 is just terrible
— Charles LaRocca. (@LaRocca504) April 18, 2022
Chill out Reggie Miller. You don’t know Herb Jones intentions. He was trying to get back to guard Chris Paul, because he’s literally the only one that can. #NOPvsPHX
— Jacob Hester (@JacobHester18) April 18, 2022
I think that was a bit reckless by Reggie Miller to say that hit was on purpose.
— Cody Taylor (@CodyTaylorNBA) April 18, 2022
I disagree with Reggie. Why would Herb Jones immediately check back for Ayton if it was on purpose? Do we think he’s trying to play 4D chess? I dunno man
— Jorge Sedano (@Sedano) April 18, 2022
The way Herb reacted, I don’t think he mean to catch him in the face? I think he’s trying to avoid Ayton to get to CP3 to pick him up full court?
— Sam Vecenie (@Sam_Vecenie) April 18, 2022
I generally enjoy Reggie Miller, but being so adamant on national television that Herb's contact with Ayton was intentional is not great.
— Justin Russo (@FlyByKnite) April 18, 2022
Herb didn't intentionally mean to run into Ayton, he was just trying to find Chris Paul. I'm not sure why Reggie Miller thought it was intentional.
— Grace (@ballerstatzz) April 18, 2022
I'm more upset with Reggie Miller trying to make Herb look like a dirty player than the Pelicans actually losing tonight
— The Mayor of Trey Town, Keeper of the Herb Garden (@PelicansMayor) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller can't be serious LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
— Jason Maples (@JJMaples55_MST) April 18, 2022
that didn’t look intentional to me at all? am i alone on this?
— Molly Morrison (@mollyhannahm) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller is convinced that Herb Jones smack on Ayton is on purpose. Are you?
It looks accidental to me because he immediately checks in on Ayton.
— Zak Noble (@Zaknoble) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller might be the dumbest commentator alive. Herb Jones has been guarding CP3 all game, that’s not on purpose and he has every reason to be rotating over to guard himself man.
— Taylor Watson (@_taylorwatson24) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller sounds like a clown. That was 100% incidental contact.
— Ross Thevenot (@BootKreweRoss) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller thinking that play by Herb Jones was on purpose is crazy. He was so definitive about it 🤦♂️ #ValleyProud
— Daniel Greer (@DanielGreer) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller thinks that was on purpose because it's something he would've done intentionally. #NOPvsPHX
— Duncan Monserud (@DuncanMonserud) April 18, 2022
Reggie Miller saying that play was dirty reminds us what kind of tricks he tried during his day.
— Jason Jones (@mr_jasonjones) April 18, 2022