5. Jonathan Taylor, Wisconsin running back

Week 9 Heisman odds: 20/1

The trend in Heisman voting favors quarterbacks, and that’s the biggest challenge for Taylor. Since 2000, only two running backs/non-quarterbacks have won the Heisman, and they both went to Alabama. But still, if others on this list struggle toward the end of the season, it could leave room for Taylor to move in.